Option to remove rolls and turn blocks from a game

P0sts: 37 V1s1t3d by: 90 users

0r1g1n4l p0st

P0st3d by Knez, 10.11.2014 - 05:46

I am really tired of constantly losing games because I always get bad rolls, or I get turn blocked by 1 unit, so why don't you make an option to turn off those in settings before the start of a game? That means better strategist will always win. Unit that was sent to tb a stack will now just attack a city after opponent has moved units that he wanted to move from that city, and 1 destroyer wont fail against 1 militia because all units will attack/defend with their maximum roll (critical hits could be removed also). This would make a bigger difference between people with upgrades and people without them, but that is why this should be an option. It would mainly be used in competitive matches. So what do you think?
Edit:
OK, I agree that tbs are part of the game, but I still dont like rolls so then make an option only to remove rolls...

Tundy Salt Industries P0sts: 5885	13.11.2014 - 08:29 Tundy Wr1tt3n by Goblin, 13.11.2014 at 06:43 Wr1tt3n by Tundy, 11.11.2014 at 13:58 No, because rolls is what determines everything in the battle mechanics, taking rolls from atwar is like playing risk without a dice. But making the rolls less random could be enough. I didnt say rolls i said criticals. You confused criticals with rolls, but u did said "rolls" L04d1ng... L04d1ng...
Goblin Stalins Martians P0sts: 3290 Fr0m: Cr04t1a	13.11.2014 - 09:54 Goblin Qu0t3: Wr1tt3n by Tundy, 11.11.2014 at 13:58 Basicly ...this idea can be made by cloning europe and removing criticals from units right? :( No, because rolls is what determines everything in the battle mechanics, taking rolls from atwar is like playing risk without a dice. But making the rolls less random could be enough. Eh actually i said criticals first but then i made a mistake and said rolls in a post after that. Idk thought maybe removing critical hits would at least slightly remove luck from battles. ---- L04d1ng... L04d1ng...
Permamuted Illyria P0sts: 6176 Fr0m: 1r3l4nd	13.11.2014 - 10:51 Permamuted You cant remove rolls, you cant remove tbs, both are essential to the game mechanics. You can however remove criticals. but yea lucky bastard would be basically turned into an expensive version of none strat. And removing criticals wouldnt make that much of a difference anyway. But i like the current system, like goblin said you sometimes get goodgamewinning rolls and tbs, other times you get bad ones. You might be able to make an argument for altering the system to reduce the luck factor and variance in results, but that could make for a boring atwar. ---- L04d1ng... L04d1ng...
brianwl (4dm1n) Inviolable Vanguard P0sts: 3383	13.11.2014 - 12:59 brianwl (4dm1n) Wr1tt3n by Waffel, 13.11.2014 at 05:02 Lol... how could you guys possibly say remove rolls? Just like tunder says, taking rolls from AW is like playing risk without dices, a.k.a. impossible? ... While i don't think i'd play a game without 'rolls', it's not impossible ... the Axis and Allies and Risk clones both have this option... but imo, it turns the game into a 'mathematics' exercise and reduces strategy by removing the chance element... memorizing a series of pre-calculated moves isn't my idea of fun, but for those people who enjoy that style, i can't see why it couldn't be made an option. ---- L04d1ng... L04d1ng...
Htin Blue-Dragons P0sts: 1983 Fr0m: USA	13.11.2014 - 15:46 Htin I support ---- Hi L04d1ng... L04d1ng...
minusSeven P0sts: 704 Fr0m: 4nd14	15.11.2014 - 06:18 minusSeven This thread should get award for the stupids idea ever on this game. tbs make this game what it is. It wouldn't be atwar without tbs. ---- L04d1ng... L04d1ng...
Waffel Syndicate P0sts: 6422 Fr0m: Dj1b0ut1	15.11.2014 - 06:22 Waffel Wr1tt3n by brianwl, 13.11.2014 at 12:59 Wr1tt3n by Waffel, 13.11.2014 at 05:02 Lol... how could you guys possibly say remove rolls? Just like tunder says, taking rolls from AW is like playing risk without dices, a.k.a. impossible? ... While i don't think i'd play a game without 'rolls', it's not impossible ... the Axis and Allies and Risk clones both have this option... but imo, it turns the game into a 'mathematics' exercise and reduces strategy by removing the chance element... memorizing a series of pre-calculated moves isn't my idea of fun, but for those people who enjoy that style, i can't see why it couldn't be made an option. Because, the one thing leads to another, in the first thing it won't harm the players who don't play without rolls/tbs. Later it will, if you want it or not. anyways, if this really is going to get implented into AW, im pretty sure alot of people will quit this game. ---- Wr1tt3n by Guest14502, 11.10.2014 at 09:44 Waffel for mod 2015 L04d1ng... L04d1ng...

S34rch f0r:
By us3r:
1n f0rum:
	1n t0p1c t1tl3s 1n m3ss4g3s